Engel O'Neill

/ YMCA OF GREATER ERIE

A unique campaign boosts summer membership revenue, earns national award

  • Print Advertising
  • TV & Radio
  • Digital Marketing
  • Website

Challenge:

When the YMCA of Greater Erie was getting set to introduce a new membership campaign that had a structure unlike anything its members had seen, it looked to Engel O’Neill to help communicate the membership structure and attract new members. It was also important to reassure existing members that not only would the new pricing offer them flexibility and savings, but also that switching over would be easy.

The choose-your-own-adventure-style price structure challenged Engel O’Neill to find a way to attract individuals and families whose membership needs fall outside traditional households; for example, grandparents who watch their grandchildren, single-parent families or divorced parents who share custody.

Strategy:

Engel O’Neill crafted messaging and imagery that:

  • Invited inclusion through immersive storytelling
  • Emphasized chosen family as a core value
  • Communicated at-a-glance membership pricing

Solutions:

Meeting people where they are

“Y Your Way” provides ultimate flexibility, fun and value, with the trademark inclusivity and community connection that define the YMCA experience built in. Engel O’ Neill crafted messaging and imagery that gave prospective members a better pathway to join, one that meets them where they are, no matter their family/chosen-family composition.

The multichannel campaign included print and digital ads, a website and TV ads that offered a series of scenarios to serve as examples of examples of how memberships could be assembled:

“My Y lets my parents bring the kids to swim while I’m at work,” said a young mom on a TV ad. “My Y lets me work out when I’m home from college. When I go back, my parents can remove me from the membership,” said a young man on another ad. “My daughter’s bestie is on our membership, so they can play together anytime,” said a young dad on another ad.

Showcasing the flexibility of chosen family

The biggest benefit to get across about the Y Your Way? Choice. With up to six available slots for each membership — known as a member’s “circle” — who’s in your circle is entirely up to you, and, as the ads emphasize, “even if you don’t share the same address.” This phrasing allows for nontraditional households or friend groups of all backgrounds to enjoy a Y membership at family-friendly rates designed to make wellness more accessible for everyone to connect, grow and thrive.

Social ads and print banners and outdoor digital boards featured close-up photos of diverse individuals and groups enjoying the Y facilities, whether in the pool, on a cardio machine or sitting at a lobby table with friends. These images helped families and friends imagine how the Y will work for their particular dynamic.

A series of videos across Facebook, Instagram and TikTok focus on specific scenarios that highlight the combination of flexibility and savings.

YMCA-Membership-Instagram-1080x1080-Artboard 2
YMCA-Membership-Instagram-1080x1080-Artboard 4

Communicating pricing clear as day

With The Y Your Way’s concept of an inner circle that allows up to 6 individuals, communicating the pricing became tantamount. Engel O’Neill graphically represented the membership rates using stick figures — ubiquitous symbols most easily understood as representative of human beings.

Next came the wording: The Y had provided the price descriptions to Engel O’Neill as the base price of an individual membership being $38, and each additional adult was added for $12 each. The rate for kids was calculated differently, but with the phrasing “Add kids $10” it was difficult to know that, especially in an ephemeral ad. As a place for families, it is super important to the Y that their new membership rates are family-friendly. Engel O’Neill proposed a refinement to the wording as “Add kids $10 total.”

Adding the word “total” made it crystal-clear that having multiple children in your circle did not incur a per-child fee. If, for example, you’re a single parent with two kids, your total would be $38 + $10, or $48 a month for you and your kids. And if each of your kids wanted to add a best friend to the circle, your membership would remain $48 a month.

This concept was reinforced in the online membership calculator Engel O’Neill built for the Y, an easy-to-use tool that makes it super easy for prospective members to input how many people would be in their circle and quickly calculate the total monthly cost.

YMCA-Calcuator-1200x1200
YMCA-Calcuator-Mobile-1200x1200

A pathway to join as vibrant as the brand colors

Engel O’Neill featured the YMCA’s vibrant pink-and-purple palette across all branded assets for the Y Your Way. Whether in outdoor ads, across digital ads or in video, the campaign graphics were extra inviting against a bright-and-beautiful background.

As experts in immersive storytelling, we know having big bold close-ups of smiling people make the storytelling more personal and more welcoming.

YMCA-Outdoor
banner-ymca

Impact:

+6%
Increase in Avg. Summer Membership Revenue
Q3 ’25 to Q3 ’26

Historically, summer had been a challenging season for YMCA membership, as families spend more time outdoors, travel, and often put memberships on hold. But Y Your Way is helping change that trend.

After introducing Y Your Way in late 2024, the YMCA of Greater Erie saw membership stabilize during its first full summer in 2025. In 2026, that momentum grew even stronger. Despite continued pressure on household budgets from rising prices, higher energy and transportation costs, and other everyday expenses, the YMCA achieved a 6% increase in summer membership retention and a 6% increase in average summer membership revenue compared to the previous year. Membership revenue is also pacing above budget for the year.

Those gains are particularly meaningful because they occurred during a time of year when families are increasingly selective about where they spend their discretionary income. Y Your Way is doing exactly what it was designed to do: Give members greater flexibility, more value and more reasons to keep the Y part of their lives year-round.

National Recognition

The campaign not only drew in new membership, it also earned the YMCA of Greater Erie 2026 Communications Excellence Award for Best Overall Campaign in its size category from the North American YMCA Development Organization. Engel O’Neill is honored to have been part of helping to drive membership numbers for the YMCA of Greater Erie, earning national recognition.

“With the help of Engel O’Neill, the YMCA of Greater Erie launched one of the most innovative membership structures among all YMCAs. Y associations around the country routinely ask us how the new structure was developed and the strategy behind the outstanding creative assets that resonated so deeply with the community. The membership calculator, in particular, is consistently praised for its clarity and ease of use. The creativity, clarity and ingenuity that the team at Engel O’Neill showed on this project is truly helping to change how our YMCA impacts the community. We couldn’t be more grateful for their partnership.”

Deanna Renaud

VP, Financial Development and Marketing, YMCA of Greater Erie

How Can We Help?

Fill out the contact form below, or call us at (814) 454-3111.